Do Pet Owners Care About Sustainable Pet Food? The Surprising Truth

September 25, 2025 | Logan Simmons

When it comes to pet food, what are pet parents really willing to pay f

When it comes to pet food, what are pet parents really willing to pay for? A recent survey sheds light on the value pet parents place on sustainability, and the results might surprise you. While sustainability is a hot topic, the survey reveals that for many consumers, it’s not a primary driver of purchasing decisions—at least not on its own.

According to the study, pet owners are highly interested in sustainability, particularly aspects related to animal welfare. However, this interest doesn’t always translate into a willingness to pay more. Core factors like high protein content, health benefits, safety, and overall quality still trump sustainability when it comes to influencing a purchase. The data showed that when sustainability was presented as a standalone attribute, it had a very minimal impact on buying behavior.

So, how can pet food brands succeed with a sustainability strategy? The answer lies in bundling. The survey found that when sustainability is combined with attributes that consumers already value, such as nutrition and health, its influence on purchasing decisions skyrockets. In fact, in a bundled format, sustainability became the second most important factor, right after price and protein type.

The survey also highlighted a key distinction: pet parents are more willing to pay for specific, actionable claims rather than a broad, vague concept of sustainability. Claims like “certified to follow animal welfare practices” and “ethically raised” resonated more strongly with consumers, who were willing to pay for these specific promises.

The takeaway for pet food companies is clear: don’t market sustainability in a vacuum. Instead, integrate sustainable features with the attributes that pet owners have already proven they will pay for. By tying sustainability to tangible benefits like animal welfare and nutrition, brands can turn consumer interest into a powerful purchasing driver.

Source – Pet Food Industry